REVIEW PROCESS

     

Introduction

The review process is very simple. It involves only two worksheets (schedules). [NOTE: Most people are not interested in the details of forms and explanations of the forms. However, in The CAFR eBook both forms are presented in a couple of ways as well as a spread sheet program and a word processing program for each of school district, city, county and State.]

A computer is not needed to conduct a review or do an economic impact analysis. All that is needed is:
   -A copy of the governments Comprehensive Annual Financial Report (CAFR)
   -Two forms
   -A sharp pencil
   -A calculator.


Steps in conducting a review and preparing the economic impact analysis

1. Get a copy of the governments/school districts most currrent Comprehensive Annual Financial Report (CAFR).

2. Go to each fund/subfund section , locate the accounts with surpluses based on the steps shown below; total them for each subfund, and write them down as shown below. In addition the Exhibit A in each of the State reports provided in this writing. The Exhibit A is the complete review. So a person has over 40 examples to use in the learning process.

3. Total the list of subfund surpluses to arrive at the total surpluses for the government.

4. Divide the result in Step 3. by the population and you have the per capita surpluses.

5. Take the total surplus amount to the proper economic impact form and complete the computations shown for each cell in the economic impact form. The computations are very simple.

That's it. The next step is preparing a report on the results of the review and economic impact analysis. Go to the Report Section of this writing.


THE COMPREHENSIVE ANNUAL FINANCIAL REPORT (CAFR) REVIEW

The Typical Table of Contents

Most Table of Contents usually have this sort of format. The Schedules in red are the ones that we will be using to determine surpluses.

Table of Contents

INTRODUCTORY SECTION Page
Letter of Transmittal............................................................................................. 1
State Government Organizations............................................................................. 8
Principal State Officials.......................................................................................... 9
FINANCIAL SECTION  
INDEPENDENT AUDITORS' REPORT........................................................................ 15
MANAGEMENT'S DISCUSSION AND ANALYSIS......................................................... 21
BASIC FINANCIAL STATEMENTS  
   
    Governmental-wide Financial Statements:  
        Statement of Net Assets............................................................................... 36
        Statement of Activities.................................................................................. 40
   
    Governmental Fund Financial Statements:  
        Balance Sheet........................................................................................... 43
        Reconciliation of the Governmental Funds Balance Sheet to the Statement of Net         Assets....................................................................................................... 44
        Statement of Revenues, Expenditures and Changes in Fund Balances..................... 45
        Reconciliation of the Statement of Revenues, Expenditures and Changes in Fund         Balances of Governmental Funds to the Statement of Activities............................ 46
   
    Proprietary Fund Financial Statements:  
        Statement of Net Assets............................................................................. 48
        Statement of Revenue, Expenses and Changes in Fund Net Assets........................ 52
        Statement of Cash Flows.............................................................................. 54
   
    Fiduciary Fund Financial Statements:  
        Statement of Fiduciary Net Assets.............................................................. 58
        Statement of Changes in Fiduciary Net Assets.................................................. 59
   
    Component Unit Financial Statements:  
        Combing Statement of Net Assets...............................................................  61
        Combing Statement of Activities..................................................................... 62
   
    Notes to the Financial Statements.................................................................... 64
   
REQUIRED SUPPLEMENTARY INFORMATION   
 (Table of Contents items not shown)  
   
COMBINING FINANCIAL STATEMENTS AND SCHEDULES  
    Governmental Funds  
        Combining Balance Sheet............................................................................... 146
        Combining Statement of Revenue, Expenditures and Changes in Fund Blances.......... 147
   
        Special Revenue Funds:  
            Combining Balance Sheet....................................................................... 150
            Combining Statement of Revenues, Expenditures and Changes in Fund Balances... 152
   
        Debt Service Funds:  
            Combining Balance Sheet....................................................................... 156
            Combining Statement of Revenues, Expenditures and Changes in Fund Balances... 158
   
        Capital Project Funds:  
               Combining Balance Sheet....................................................................... 162
            Combining Statement of Revenues, Expenditures and Changes In Fund Balances... 163
   
    Proprietary Funds:  
        Enterprise Funds:  
            Combining Statement of Net Assets......................................................... 166
            Combining Statement of Revenues, Expenses and Changes in Fund Balances........ 168
            Combining Statement of Cash Flows............................................................. 170
   
        Internal Service Funds:  
            Combining Statement of Net Assets......................................................... 174
            Combining Statement of Revenues, Expenses and Changes in Fund Balances........ 176
            Combining Statement of Cash Flows............................................................. 178
   
    Fiduciary Funds:  
        Pension Trust Funds:  
            Combining Statement of Fiduciary Net Assets............................................. 182
          Combining Statement of Changes in Fiduciary Net Assets................................. 183
   
        Investment Trust Funds:  
            Combining Statement of Fiduciary Net Assets............................................. 186
          Combining Statement of Changes in Fiduciary Net Assets................................. 187
   
        Agency Funds:  
            Combining Statement of Assets and Liabilities............................................ 191
          Combining Statement of Changes in Assets and Liabiliities................................ 192
   
 STATISTICAL SECTION  
        (Many items shown here)  
        Population by County for the Last Ten Years.................................................. 216
etc.  

You can see that the schedules in red are not very many. Now there are three schedules that are in green. Whether there are surpluses in these three schedules depends on circumstances which wil be explained later.


What type of accounts are we interested in

Here is a partial list of the types of names that are given to cash and investment type accounts. There are more in the reports in this writing:

Amounts on deposit with U.S. Treasury
Cash and cash equivalents
Cash and Investments
Cash and pooled investments
Cash and securities held in trust
Cash and temporary investments
Cash equity with Treasurer
Cash held by trustee
Cash on deposit with agents
Cash with fiscal agents
Collateral on lent securities
Dedicated Investments
Equity in pooled cash and investments
Investment in [certain fund or project]
Investments Investments held by trustee
Investments net amortization
Investments, noncurrent
Net investment in direct financing assets
Other assets
Pooled Investments with State Treasury
Securities lending cash collateral
Restricted cash and cash equivalents
Restricted investments

In the schedules listed below the cash and investments that are used to compute the surpluses are marked in red.


Items not Included

The following items are not included in the amount of surplus shown:

-Buildings, roads, bridges, land (not for sale), and equipment.

-Deferred compensation plans for employees. These are plans in which the employee contributes to his/her retirement over and above the normal employee retirement contribution.

-Any fund that is 100% supported by donations, bequests, gifts, endowments, etc. These are not taxpayers money.

-For Colleges and Universities. All endowment and similar-type funds should not be included as surpluses. Sometimes these funds are combined with other college/university funds. We are interested in surpluses, so in these cases the total amount should not be included.

-Funds in which the revenues/contributions are 100% held for other individuals, organizations or another government. (Note: There are sometimes problems in the way these funds are described and can result in the fund being considered surplus due to the lack of enough information.)

-Funds that are required by law in which a bank, financial institution, insurance companies, etc. are required to deposit with the government a certain amount for insurance against the entity going bankrupt. These are not taxpayers' money.

-Retirement/Pension Funds - only included are 1/2 of the actuarially determined excesses, the taxpayers portion. The other 1/2 is the government employees portion.


What Schedules Do we Look At

In the CAFR we are only interested in certain schedules in that massive document you have of schedules. These are the schedules you will be looking at:

Balance Sheets
Combining Balance Sheets
Statement of Net Assets
Combining Statement of Fiduciary Net Assets
Combining Schedule of Accounts

We forget about the rest of the schedules. This means that we have excluded almost 2/3 of the schedules. Now we are down to less than 35 schedules (pages) for States and much less for school districts, cities, and counties. I have had school districts that I used only 10 schedules (pages) to conduct the review of the CAFR. With a State CAFR of over 200 or more pages, 35 max is very little.


Basic Financial Statements

Go to the Section called "Basic Financial Statements" in the CAFR.

Note: The page number shown next to the "(Expressed in Thousands)" is added so that you can see in the Table Of Contents what schedule is being used.

The first schedule you see looks something like this:

Statement of Net Assets
June 30,2003
(Expressed in Thousands)- Page 36

                         PRIMARY GOVERNMENT
  Governmental Activities Business-Type
Activities
Total Primary
Government
Component Units
ASSETS:         
   Current Assets:         
      Cash 2,132 93,200 95,332 13,341
      Cash with U.S. Treasury   860,872 860,872  
      Cash and pooled investments with State       Treasurer 1,537,024 169,818 1,706,842 53,497
      Cash held by trustee       24,489
      etc.        

You can forget the above-type schedule. These data will be provided again broken down into something meaningful. Note: I have put the page number so that you can relate to the Table of Contents for the schedule.


Governmental Funds

This is the first schedule that is important. The figures in red are the surpluses.

The Page Nr. 146 shows the page in which the Other Governmental Funds are shown in more detail, so they are not used here for surpluses.

Balance Sheet
GOVERNMENTAL FUNDS
June 30,2003
(Expressed In Thousands)-Page 43

  General Fund Transportation & Aviation Planning Highway Maintenance & Safety Fund Land Endowments Fund (Page 146) Other Governmental Funds
Assets      
    Cash 719   28 1,385
    Cash and pooled investments with     State Treasurer 564,659 151,425 60,203 691,158
    Receivables, net of allowance        
        Taxes 286,869 68,683   7,832
        Interest 15,697 861 2,143 2,476
        Loans and Notes     260,229  
        Other 26,718 18,366 548 22,801
    Due from U.S. Government 148,021 69,929   153
    Due from local governments 1,577 41    
    Due from others       9
    Due from other funds 276,216 20,264 291 57,607
    Inventory of food stamps 86      
    Inventories, at cost 11,300 4,693   2,607
    Restricted assets        
        Cash and pooled investments with         State Treasurer 18,259 312,889   192,697
        Cash held by trustee 86,843     33,611
    Endowment investments     1,119,469  
    Other 344     27
         
    Total Assets 1,437,308 647,151 1,142,911 1,012,363
 (Following not part of schedule)        
Total Surpluses... 670,480 464,314 1,179,700  

Proprietary Funds

This is the second schedule that is important. The figures in red are the surpluses.

Statement of Net Assets
PROPRIETARY FUNDS
June 30,2003
(Expressed In Thousands)-Page 48

                                                                        BUSINESS ACTIVITES-ENTERPRISE FUNDS

  Universities Unemployment Compensation Industrial Commission Other
Assets      
    Current Assets:        
        Cash 86,749 29 6,087 332
        Cash with U.S. Treasury   860,872    
        Cash and pooled investments with         State Treasurer 115,978 308 18,596
        Collateral investment pool 34,251   35,274  
        Short-term investments 50,325     60
        Receivables, net of allowance        
            Taxes 39,659  
            Interest 582 2,054 310
            Loans and Notes 4,320   4,357 
            Other 40,274 11,692 17 4,766
        Due from U.S. Government 53,234 11,692 17  58
        Due from local governments   381 
        Due from other funds 109,632
        Inventories, at cost 17,326   7,939
        Other Current Assets 4,442     567
                Total Current Assets 407,481 912,252 43,740 146,998
         
    Non-Current Assets:        

        Restricted assets:
       
            Cash 92,446      
            Cash and pooled investments with             State Treasurer   102,398
            Cash held by trustee 25,809    
            Investments held by trustee 103,174   3,387  
        Loans and notes receivable, net of         allowance 27,838     24,256
        Investments 157,321   185,404  
        Endowment investments 208,783    
        Other long-term assets 10,227     179
        Capital assets:        
            Infracstructure, land and other             non-depeciable 296,227   2,997 2,063
            Depreciable buildings, property and             equipment 3,465,743   27,303 55,587
            Less: accumulated depreciation (1,628,342)   (5,584) (35,897)
                Total Noncurrent Assets 2,758,226   213,507 148,586
    Total Assets 3,166,707 912,252 257,247 295,584
 (Following not part of schedule)        
Total Surpluses... 680,722 860,901 230,460 122,132

Only a few of the schedules are shown because most people are not really interested in the details. [NOTE: In The CAFR eBook every schedule is shown with the surpluses annotated.]